Skip to content

Horseshoe Hideaway Traditional Geocache

This cache has been archived.

Wis Kid: At the request of the Wisconsin DNR, this cache will have to be archived. Note that DNR regulations require that owners of geocaches placed on DNR property make regular maintenance visits and keep notification forms up to date with current contact information. If you would like to have this listing reinstated, please contact Emily Bley at Peninsula State Park, and have her contact me to indicate that the situation is to her satisfaction.

Wis Kid - Volunteer Reviewer

More
Difficulty:
2 out of 5
Terrain:
5 out of 5

Size: Size:   regular (regular)

Join now to view geocache location details. It's free!

Watch

How Geocaching Works

Please note Use of geocaching.com services is subject to the terms and conditions in our disclaimer.

Geocache Description:

This cache is located on Horseshoe Island, off of the coast of Peninsula State Park in Door County, Wisconsin.


Of all the islands visible from Peninsula's scenic overlooks only one, Horseshoe Island, is actually part of the park. It lies about one mile north of Nicolet Bay.
Norwegian immigrant Ole Larsen reportedly traded a few pounds of tobacco for the island in the 1850s. In 1888, the Folda family purchased Horseshoe Island for $500. They built an impressive summer lodge, Engelmar. When the State of Wisconsin established Peninsula State Park in 1909, E.F. Folda negotiated a selling price of $5,000 and a life estate for himself as well as his wife and sister, but they never received payment.
Horseshoe Island is accessible by boat or by walking in winter. Visitors can also canoe or kayak, with rentals available locally. The Engelmar Trail, a one-mile rustic path, meanders the circumference of the island. The astute visitor may detect the foundation of the Folda's lodge, a root cellar, and openings where gardens once thrived.
A pit toilet is available. Visitors must carry out their own garbage. Camping and fires are prohibited.

Too many caches in Door County are located on busy roads, or places where there's lots of people. I wanted to place a cache off of the beaten path.

Horseshoe Island is part of Peninsula State Park. There is no public transportation, so you will have to get to the island somehow, either with a boat in summer, or skiing/snowmobiling in winter. There is a boat dock available, but if full, you may have to moor it and swim/wade ashore. Horseshoe Island harbor is pretty deep, so most boats are OK. Closest boat launch is in Nicolet Bay, but a park sticker is required to park/launch inside the park. Beware of treacherous ice in wintertime, though, especially on a snowmobile.

Other than pit toilets and a fire ring, there are no amenities on the island. Didn't see any water faucets or pumps. There is no overnight camping on the island itself, but you can moor offshore overnight.

There is a hiking trail that follows the perimeter of the island, and the cache is located off of this trail a few dozen yards.

The cache is an ammo can. Once you're on the island, it's not too traumatic to reach, so little ones should be OK, but strollers will not work.

As you may guess, this isn't a cache I can keep a close eye on, so if something is amiss, let me know.

Mini-Spoiler: The cache is located in a fairly typical fashion, such as under a fallen log, or in a tree's base, or any of the normal cache hiding spots. Nothing too sinister about the actual placement.

If you don't have a boat, rentals are available in both Nicolet Bay in the park, or in Ephraim.
Nicolet Bay is the closest departure point to Horseshoe Island.

Additional Hints (No hints available.)