It's exactly where you think it is! Keep looking, it's there. After you find it, if it's a weekday between 9am and 5pm, stop by my work place (the title of the cache) and ask to see Sarah, I would love to come out and chat for a few minutes with you! You'll encounter less muggles on the weekend or on weekday evenings, though.
Congratulations to GnomeGCer, Biblical, SetterSearcher, and Kitty Chaser for the FTF!!