The above coordinates are for the nearby path, not the cache. Convenient parking can be found on Penn Gardens.
Originally there were two chocolate coins inside for the FTF and the cache container was a special festive one (a gold bauble) hidden in amongst "the holly and the ivy". I had to change it in the New Year to something more waterproof. At which point I also moved it along the park to a better location.
The puzzle: Some like Red Sauce some like Brown. Are you someone who thinks the answer is all in the sauce?