All I can say is wow! Perrot Island 2 and Perrot Island 1 have to be the scariest caches we have ever attempted. Yesterday we saw that Oma and Opa had walked across the hard water to these caches. We parked in the nearby parking area and proceeded to the hard water. We "tested" the ice and it seemed ok so off we went. We got over by the support for the old bridge and the ice was so clear we could see a bug crawling under the ice. That was kinda cool. We continued on and went under the railroad bridge. We can hear the water gurgling under the ice and can hear the ice cracking. This is REAL eerie. We get just a little ways past the bridge and the ice gives a really loud crack. My initial reaction was to run for shore but we stopped and looked at each other trying to decide what to do. Roger said there was no way he was walking across that ice. It's about .35 to the island. I decided to go on alone while Roger watched from the safety of the shore. I proceeded slowly with caution listening to the gurgling and cracking all the way. I got a little more than half way there and the ice cracked REALLY bad-I could have sworn I felt it crack. Decision time-do I forge ahead or go back?? I decided to continue my journey-probably not one of my smartest decisions but none the less the decision has been made so off I go. After what seemed like an enternity I reached the shore. Climbed up the bank and found Perrot Island 2 without any problems. After signing the log and replacing as found I bushwacked my way to Perrot Island 1. Upon reaching gz I looked around and didn't see the cache. Roger called and I told him I hadn't found it. He said "you may just have to wait til spring and we can come out in the boat." I said no I know it is here and I'm not leaving until I find it!! I no sooner got off the phone and what do I see?? The cache but how do I get it?? Hmmm......After some improvising I managed to retrieve the container and sign the log but now the hard part begins. Just how am I ever going to get it back where I found it. It took a few tries but I finally got it done!! I called Roger, who by this time is watching with binoculars from the tracks, and told him I was on my way back. Once I got on the ice I could see him almost directly across from me. My plan was to go so straight across and then climb the rocky hill and walk the tracks back. I headed towards him and again the water is gurgling and the ice is cracking. I didn't make it very far when we both noticed like a ledge in the ice. Didn't look like I wanted to go that way so I turned around and head back to the island. Walked along the edge until I got to a spot to head back across. I finally made it back to the safety of shore. On the way home we heard a car went through the ice on Lake Onalaska so now I am especially relieved to have made it back safely.