Shadowski84: After checking around, I have decided to archive this cache.
It is just outside my easy access range for maintenance now, and was never intended to require more then a rare checkup. I am still not sure how a small signpost cache went missing so much, but I would rather open this area up to a more local geocacher to put a nice cache in.
Thanks for letting me know it was gone! :)
The cache was a magnetic hollowed out bolt, and I am quite sorry to see it gone. Moreso then a standard plastic tube. Oh well.