We usually do our caching without a GPS. Tonight it was just getting dark as we finished the nearby History cache but we thought we'd continue on and try doing this one.
We'd previously failed in July when searching for it so we thought we'd need to use our borrowed GPS. This took us to exactly where we'd searched before, but this time there was the cache sitting there in the open at the bottom of a tree. Local muggles I guess - we hid it a little better when we left.
Left a Maltese coin and a US quarter.