Batter Up! Mystery Cache
Please note Use of geocaching.com services is subject to the terms and conditions
in our disclaimer.
Congratulations to jcanyoneer and AZCampbell for the FTF!!!
NOTE: The cache is NOT at the coordinates listed.
UPDATE: The other 2 caches have been archived. The YANKEES answer was "C". The DIAMONBACKS answer was "E". Also, the eastern route is now cut off due to private property. You'll need to choose a different direction, but it is still reachable.
I've had the pleasure of living in the Phoenix area since 2001. I moved here from Seattle, which some of you may know, hasn't had a great history of baseball success (they had some good years, but overall - not so great). I was glad to see the opposite when I moved here (at least for that one year). When I moved here, all of my friends and co-workers were talking about the 2001 World Series and how excited they were to watch the Arizona Diamondbacks beat the New York Yankees!!!
Most people want a World Series to always go to a game 7 and love watching that final game. Not me! I do enjoy the final game, but I always like watching game 1. It really positions what to expect out of the series I'm about to watch. With this mindset, I watched game 1 of the 2001 series and was excited to see the Yankees lose (apologies to any Yankess fans out there, ever since I saw fans in Yankee Stadium throw D cell batteries at Ken Griffey Jr, I have had a severe dislike for that team).
Where was I? Oh yes - game 1. I really enjoyed watching game 1, especially the first inning. I am of 2 minds about who my favorite players were from each team though. Perhaps you can help remind me by finding my other 2 caches Arizona Diamondbacks and New York Yankees (look for the letter A-E written on the top of each logsheet).
For the Yankees, it was either:
A = Brosius, Posada and Mussina
B = Justice, Brosius and Jeter
C = Jeter, Mussina and Brosius
D = Soriano, Knoblauch and Williams
E = Jeter, Brosius and Martinez
For the Diamondbacks, it was either:
A = Finley, Sanders and Counsell
B = Grace, Womack and Schilling
C = Schilling, Miller and Gonzalez
D = Gonzalez, Sanders and Grace
E = Sanders, Finley and Williams
(And please,even though I said "help remind me", don't post any answers/spoilers here! Thanks!)
This is in the desert and on state trust land. Therefore the usual license and desert creature comments apply.
Original Swag: Official American League baseball, Toy car, Small purse filled with hair toys (in ziplock bag to keep clean), nail clippers (new in packaging), Garden Gnome Stake, tweasers (every geocacher needs one), keychain led flashlight, yoyo, arizona golf club keychain, screwdriver, $1 gold coin, 200 lire coin, 2 francs coin

Additional Hints
(Decrypt)
[Puzzle:] Onfronyy vf n tnzr nobhg ahzoref. Vs n SGS qbrfa'g unccra fbba, V'yy vzcebir guvf uvag. Nyfb, gur gvgyr vf abg n uvag - vgf fvzcyl n cuenfr gung erzvaqf zr bs onfronyy.
[Hide:] Nzzb obk uvqqra va glcvpny Nevmban fglyr.
Treasures
You'll collect a digital Treasure from one of these collections when you find and log this geocache:

Loading Treasures