*Edit: I've bumped the difficulty rating from it's original 3 to 4.5, to try and give a more accurate gauge of the amount of time/number of times it may take to find. Don't lose heart however, I think you'll find the challenge well worth it in the end*
This cache is hidden around the area of the Nappanee Public Library. Ample parking is available, both in the public lot (free), and along the street. The cache is a clever little hide, requiring a bit of geo-sense on your part. You DO NOT need to enter/climb the structure housing the dumpsters, in order to find this cache. Be on the lookout for Muggles, as this can be a highly trafficked area at times. Please be sure to replace the cache as found. Also, be sure to bring your own pen/pencil for this cache. After you've completed the hunt, take some time to enjoy downtown Nappanee.
Congratulations to TJNS, for claiming the honor, FTF!