Just discovered this lake, and I can't believe that there is only one cache on almost 300 acres of water.This large, camoed pill bottle will be the first of two that I have planned.
You will have to climb onto the island to make the grab (unless you have amazingly long arms to make a difficult 10-foot reach). Thus, NTGOOB.
Might be a reasonable spot for a picnic, though it needs some CITO, and then there's the title.