Capers4: I'm kind of sad to archive this one since it really is a nice spot to see the water and look at the Toronto skyline and I enjoyed bringing people here to see it.
I checked on it today since there hadn't been any finds since it was replaced a month ago. I could see the container down over the cliff on the beach where it had been thrown. I know I could replace it, but once a hiding spot is compromised there really isn't a point in replacing a cache over and over and changing it to a bison or fake bolt just wouldn't be the same. I'll probably use the idea again somewhere a little less muggle ridden.
Thanks to everyone who found it. The spot is now open for anyone who wants to try keeping a cache here.