The cache is not at the posted coordinates. However, you'll need to go to the posted coordinates in order to figure out where the geocache is hidden.
The cache can be found at the following coordinates: N40 50.8AB W73 47.1CD
A - What was the Police Officer's name?
- Roger Murtaugh - 3
- Pasquale J. Venturelli - 0
- Jimmy "Popeye" Doyle - 4
B - What was his badge number?
- 5200 - 3
- 3778 - 7
- 4001 - 4
C - In what year was the Police Officer killed?
- 1943 - 9
- 1989 - 5
- 1962 - 7
D - Who provided the placard you are reading?
- The Police Officer's family - 8
- The Centurian Foundation - 7
- City Island - 5
You can check your answer here:
Don't be a Muggle and do this on-line. Visit the site to solve the puzzle and take a minute to show respect to the fallen Officer's memorial.