Rules for this puzzle: No intentional red herrings and no leaving off the N32 and W96 just to make it more difficult. There may be more than one layer on this puzzle. Collaboration is allowed and you may ask me for hints after there has been a FTF.
Love letters to multiple girlfriends
Apparently you can forget your feelings when they're standing right in front of you
Everything goes wrong 10x over
Italian anti-semitism
Celibacy 101
Four weddings for the price of one
The Devil Incarnate
There are two kinds of children
Time to fake your own death
Comedic fighting
Time to hate humankind
Someone probably should stop that man
How to backstab your buddy in front of your buddies and his buddies
Cast away v2.0

You can validate your puzzle solution with certitude.