In early April, we went to find a MatthewCat geocache in Salt Hill State forest, which is s hidden gem between Yorktown and Croton. On the hike there, we came across this location. It reminded us very much of a now-archived cache near Fahenstock:
Claustrophobia or THE RING
This in an homage to that cache, which took us two (perhaps three?) times to finally locate. We hope you have better luck here!