This geocache will require a boat, and is not recommended to be done alone. It is NOT located at the posted coordinates.
The correct coordinates are on this page. Really. Like right here... N 41° 24.749 W 74° 44.338.
Finding the coordinates is not meant to be difficult. Tleccw pva pfstl xipgpn xff fcyh.
A wise person once pointed out that a good puzzle writer WANTS someone to solve the puzzle. It doesn't need to be difficult. So, please, won't you solve this puzzle and come and find this geocache.
Pretty please, with a cherry on top.