The cache is not at the posted coordinates. It is a mystery cache, after all.
I was thinking of making a totally different kind of puzzle, but I decided to go with this. It's al ittle bit weird, but I think it's pretty good.
I was working on a playlist when I realized that it would be perfect for a mystery cache. Here's the playlist:
American Idiot
Under the Bridge (and) Give It Away
I Want It That Way
U Can't Touch This
Radioactive
Do I Make You Proud
Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm
Nothin' on You
Complicated
Lump
Mony Mony
Royals
Bad
Livin' On The Edge
Jeopardy
Good luck! The cache itself is a NAEPAG. BYOP. Enjoy!

You can validate your puzzle solution with certitude.
Congrats to kcmcacher for getting FTS and carlthepickle for getting FTF!