I found What Are The Chances? a few hours and miles back in my hike, and was amazed my the story in the description. How is that possible?! Well, turns out, it's not too crazy!
I noticed a gap as I made my way down Wagon Road, and was a bit bored, so decided to venture a bit off trail and see if it was a good spot for a new cache. As I made my way back here, I turned back towards the trail to see a hole in the back of an oak. Perfect! But wait, what's that rock doing in there? I took the rock out and was amazed to find a small camoed (peanut butter?) jar in great shape! My immediate thought was puzzle final, but I remembered I had certainly solved all the ones within two miles, if there even are any. I opened it up and found a blank log: so not an archived cache either. I signed myself in and decided I'd message the usual suspects when I got home and ask if it was theirs. Geokashers figured it was likely his, and told me to go ahead and publish it myself (thanks!). Never thought it was possible to find a container in the vast land of Coe without coordinates and a hint, but turns out I was wrong!