Christmas Cookie Catastrophe

It was a chilly December evening in Whoville, and every Who down in Whoville was bustling about, preparing for Christmas. Up on Mount Crumpit, the Grinch sat in his recliner, sipping a mug of hot cocoa and glaring at the glow from the town below.
"Christmas cookies!" he sneered, watching a Who family decorating their window with gingerbread men. "Every year, those Whos bake their sugary nonsense. Bah! I’ll show them cookies!"
Despite his grumpy demeanor, a peculiar idea began to form in the Grinch’s mind. “What if I… made cookies?” The thought was absurd, even to him. But as he paced his lair, the idea refused to leave. Maybe this year, instead of stealing Christmas, he’d try something new.
"Max!" he called to his loyal dog, who trotted over eagerly. "We’re going to bake. Prepare yourself!"
The Grinch wasn’t exactly a culinary expert, but his lair was oddly equipped with all sorts of odds and ends. He scrounged together ingredients: flour, sugar, eggs, and something he thought might be vanilla. "Perfect!" he declared, although Max tilted his head skeptically at the bag labeled “garlic powder.”
He dumped everything into a giant bowl and began stirring furiously. The batter became a lumpy, sticky mess. "Cooking is easy," he muttered, wiping flour on his green fur. "I don’t know why those Whos make such a fuss."
When it came time to shape the cookies, the Grinch got creative. He rolled out the dough and cut it into grotesque shapes—a blob that vaguely resembled himself, a lopsided tree, and something he called "Max’s tail." Satisfied, he shoved them into the oven, setting the timer with a confident smirk.
Disaster struck almost immediately. The cookies expanded like mutant marshmallows, smoke began pouring from the oven, and an acrid smell filled the room.
"MAX!" the Grinch howled, yanking open the oven door. Burnt, gooey blobs oozed onto the floor. "What went wrong?!" He frantically fanned the smoke, muttering, "Maybe a little too much… garlic."
Max barked, nudging the cookbook the Grinch had ignored earlier. "Fine!" he grumbled, flipping through the pages. "Let’s try it your way, chef."
This time, the Grinch followed the recipe step by step—begrudgingly measuring and mixing. To his surprise, the dough was smooth and smelled… delightful. He even let Max press the cookie cutter into shapes, resulting in adorable little gingerbread dogs.
As the cookies baked, the Grinch’s lair began to fill with a warm, sweet aroma. "Hmm," he muttered, trying to ignore the smile creeping onto his face. When the timer dinged, he pulled out a tray of perfectly golden cookies.
Feeling unusually generous, the Grinch decided to share his creation. He loaded a basket with his cookies and made his way down to Whoville. The Whos were surprised, to say the least, when the Grinch appeared at their door with a sheepish grin and a plate of cookies.
The youngest Who, Cindy-Lou, took a bite and beamed. "These are the best cookies ever, Mr. Grinch!"
For the first time, the Grinch felt his heart swell—not from greed or scheming, but from joy. "Merry Christmas," he mumbled, though it came out gruff.
That night, the Grinch learned that maybe—just maybe—Christmas wasn’t about stealing or sulking. Sometimes, it was about baking a batch of cookies, making a mess, and sharing a little sweetness with the world.
Some of the Grinchmas caches will have a code written on the inside of the cap. Be sure to look under the cap and record the codes you see. The codes will be needed to find the final bonus cache.
You can validate your puzzle solution with
certitude.