The Cache is not at the posted coordinates. They are in the parking lot for the Rutgers SHI Football Stadium, which is a convenient place to park.
You must complete the "Birthplace of College Football" Adventure Lab to obtain the coordinates to this cache. This cache is a bonus for completing the Adventure Lab.
After you complete Birthplace of College Football Adventure Lab, the final coordinates for this bonus cache will be displayed in the Adventure Lab app within the Journal. Use the Groundspeak Adventure Lab app and locate the link for "Birthplace of College Football" or scan the QR code below.
If you do not wish to complete the “Birthplace of College Football" Adventure Lab, you may alternatively solve this puzzle to obtain the final coordinates.
N Action Approve Above August
W Came Appear About Content
*** You may log this cache even if you logged the prior (now Archived) bonus cache "Adventure Lab ~ Birthplace of College Football Bonus" and previously completed the corresponding Adventure Lab. This bonus cache is in the same location. ***