islander1988: Unfortunately it looks like the cache has been muggled again. Since I can't get there in a timely fashion to replace it, and this one was a bit out of the way for maintaining anyway, I've made the decision to archive the cache. Perhaps someone else will see fit to put a cache here in the future so more geocachers can find this spot.
Thanks to the 50+ people who logged a find over its almost 10 year life!