Found Tick Tag! It was still in Above Sausalito, though I can only log it as grabbing it from somewhere else. Intrigued by another cacher's log and a historic artifact nearby that I did not visit a few days ago, I decided to return to this cache and check it once more. While there I did some maintenance for the CO, emptying the cache contents and drying everything out. Buried beneath the damp swag was Tick Tag! 😁 As noted in The Appeal O Bells 10/14/21, it is a little block of wood now.
Since it does not look like a typical trackable, it probably got overlooked while in Above Sausalito. I rescued Tick Tack and will clean it up and find a new home for it shortly.