You should log it out of the cache, Read and Recycle (archived anyway) as it is still shown there using the secret number on the tag, the one that begins with 49xxxx and then drop it in another cache so it can continue on it's journey to hang out with other cachers.
If you need more help, just write me directly, bitbucket@otwc.net I'll be in Dayton May 16th-21 if that helps.
Thanks for checking in, appreciate you asking...Mike, Cinch's owner, Mazama WA