Sorry to report that I, too, did not see this coin in the Cooley Lake cache when I was there last Sunday. The prior finder, the only other known cacher to find this cache in almost a year also noted this in her find log. A signature for a "Riley" in the cache log may indicate a muggle discovered this cache and stole some items, including the coin. Other finders in the past couple years since the coin was dropped in the cache did not mention the coin. Probably will have to mark it mia for now. Sorry. 😟