We found it! Yay! The tracking number on the coin is almost completely scratched off - it took a good 15 minutes of guessing to figure out all the digits. There was also no info sheet in the cache for this coin(unless I somehow missed it).
I will print up a new info sheet, and will make sure to put the tracking number on the info sheet as well, to save future finders some time and keep this in circulation as long as possible.
We'll drop the coin in a new cache by the end of this weekend - in a different state as requested. Hopefully it'll get around to a few new places before school lets out for the summer!