Skip to content

The Mystery of Sadie McMullen Mystery Cache

Hidden : 9/21/2007
Difficulty:
4 out of 5
Terrain:
3 out of 5

Size: Size:   regular (regular)

Join now to view geocache location details. It's free!

Watch

How Geocaching Works

Please note Use of geocaching.com services is subject to the terms and conditions in our disclaimer.

Geocache Description:


On the night of October 31, 1890 in the village of Akron, New York a seventeen year old girl named Sadie McMullen took two young girls out onto the middle of the Cement Works trestle.  The trestle spanned Murder Creek Ravine, connecting the cement mill to the mainline railroad at a height of 52 feet.

                                                   

Once in the middle of the trestle, Sadie McMullen instructed the girls to sit down. In an instant she rose up and hurled eight-year old Nellie May Connor off of the bridge. Six-year old Delia Brown screamed and in a moment, McMullen was upon her, clasped her  hand over he little girls mouth and pushed her out into the darkness.

Nellie May Connor fell, striking her head on a stone abutment- she was killed instantly. Delia Brown managed to miraculously survive and when she was discovered beneath the bridge by a search party at 3 AM, the first words she uttered were, "Sadie thought she was real smart throwing us off the bridge, didn't she?"

                         

On March 5, 1891 facing death by electrocution, Sadie McMullen appeared in the court of Oyer and Terminer to stand trial for the murder at Akron of  Nellie May Connor. After a three day trial she was found not guilty by reason of insanity.

Justice Loren Lewis remanded Sadie McMullen into the custody of the Erie County Sheriff and sentenced Miss McMullen to stay in the Buffalo State Hospital under the care of Dr. Judson B. Andrews until such time as she was cured. 

                  

On August 19, 1893 Sadie McMullen was released from the Buffalo State Hospital and never seen or heard from again. Did she really make it out of that horrific place alive? Did she become a hermit and live alone in the forest? Did she join a jug band and assume another name?   Many rumors surround her disappearance but none have been substantiated.

To complete this puzzle you will have to do some legwork. You will be investigating the mysterious events following that horrific Halloween night, and visiting some of the actual places where this strange but true story took place. If you are ready to delve into the macabre, you may learn the secrets surrounding, "The Mystery of Sadie McMullen".

The clue you will need to find Sadie McMullen is in a square tupperware type container at N43 03.ABC W078 47.DEF

A= the number of letters in the first name of the District Attorney for the Prosecution of Sadie McMullen. B= the number of letters in his last name. C= the number of letters in the first name of Sadie McMullen's attorney. D= the first digit plus the third digit of the year the state of New York established electrocution as the official method of execution. E= the day of the month the state of New York established electrocution as the official method of execution. F= the first digit plus the last digit of the year the state of New York established electrocution as the official method of execution.

         Here is a link to an interesting video about the  Tragedy at Murder Creek . It may help you with your research.

  Have fun with your investigation. Don't forget to bring a pen and some sturdy footwear.

           Congratulations to  team scrunchy and  Skeeterbait2  on FTF!

Additional Hints (Decrypt)

Fgnl ba gur genvy sebz yrt 1 gb gur svany. Lbh bayl unir gb ohfujunpx fvkgl srrg.

Decryption Key

A|B|C|D|E|F|G|H|I|J|K|L|M
-------------------------
N|O|P|Q|R|S|T|U|V|W|X|Y|Z

(letter above equals below, and vice versa)