LibLabLady: Sadly, a storm tide took the cache. [V] As soon as I drove up to check, I said "oh oh!" Debris from the tide was a couple feet inland. The beach had been totally rearranged, including the large log the cache had been in. As ICEman said, the logs had to been carried there at some point.
We will try to resurrect this cache at some time in the future. The views from this location are soooo lovely! It is the treasure.
Thanks to the folks who found it, and thanks to the folks for searching.