Chumpo: I decided to go ahead and pull this cache out of play. The container is in need of a bit of repair work, and after four years and 100+ finds, it is time to let someone else make use of this area. Thank you to all of the visitors this cache has had over the years, and a super HUGE thank you to the priests, Brothers and Sisters of Saint Michael's CMRI parish for their hospitality.
Be on the lookout for this container to reappear as a new cache eventually!